We have taken some online adoption/parenting classes as part of our home study. One of them spoke a lot about how it always feels like something is missing in an adoptive family because the children don't have a biological connection to the parents. One adoption story was an adopted girl talking about giving birth to her daughter and how it completed her because here was someone biologically connected to her.
Maybe I'm naive, but I think that's sad. Granted, I was not adopted. I look like both my parents and my brothers all look a lot like my dad. I have a biological connection to both of my parents, three siblings, and lots of aunts, uncles, cousins, and a wonderful grandmother, so maybe I just can't understand.
But even with all those people with similar DNA around me, the person I'm closest to in this world is someone I don't share any biological connection with: Isaac. I've never wished he had the same blood running through his veins as I do. I've never felt the need to talk to one of my brothers about something instead of talking to Isaac. I've never felt like Isaac couldn't understand me the way my cousin could. The lack of a biological connection just doesn't matter.
I suppose it could be argued that it's different because spouses are supposed to be unrelated but children are "supposed to" be related to their parents, but in my eyes the principle is the same. Plus, I've known friends who were closer than sisters, and people with no family who, though they wish they had one, were as complete as I am.
I've heard people say that they don't want to have some kids the traditional way and some kids adopted because they think they'd automatically favor the kids they gave birth to, but I think that's ridiculous. Ask any person you know who has both adopted and birth kids, and they will tell you honestly that they love them all the same; they are all 100% their kids. I think this biological connection thing is bigger to the adopted children than to the adoptive parents, but I still can't see why it'd be such a big deal that they would feel incomplete without someone biologically related to them.
I'm not saying that I'm going to expect our kids to adopt all their kids as well. Wanting to give birth to kids that look like you is normal. We'll be fine with it if that's what they want to do. I'm not saying we're not going to talk about the adoption or not be ready for the kids to say things about wishing they knew what their birth parents looked like or if they have any blood siblings. But I just don't think it's as big a deal as some people make it, or that it's necessary to truly be close to someone.
What do you think?
'K, let me gather my thoughts.
ReplyDeleteI agree, and I don't. I didn't have kids because I wanted little people running around who "look like me." For some reason, it really bothers me when you say that. I had kids because I *wanted* to bring little people into the world. I never thought about adoption because I've always wanted to be pregnant and birth children (okay, that sounds weird, I know).
I think it's wonderful that God laid on your heart adopting, and Isaac's as well, but it seems you emphasize a bit much how it doesn't matter to you if your kids look like you or not, and implied in that is that people only have kids because they want kids that look like them. But there are plenty of parents who have kids that don't look like them.
I know you don't look down on those who choose to birth their own kids, but some times that how you come across and I don't think you're aware of it.
Then again, maybe it's just me.
I agree, though, that there's probably no greater bond for most adoptive parents for their own kids v. their adopted kids. That's horse pucky that you can't feel as much attachment for those who aren't related by blood. I know there are stories of adoptive parents who don't feel a bond with their adopted kids (in fact, I read a heartbreaking story about a woman who GAVE BACK her adopted daughter when she was two. That made me very angry), but there are also parents of biological kids who don't have a bond.
Love is a choice. I love my kids, not because they're related to me, but because they're my kids. Whether related or not, they're mine. There are days I have to choose to love them, but I always do.
Wow, I hope all that makes sense. And please don't take offense at what I said. I know you're not mean or condescending, but it's just how you come across sometimes.
Hmm, maybe I should come up with a new phrase to communicate that people want kids that... share their DNA. But then, that doesn't really work either, because we all have the same basic human DNA, whether we're related or not. Hmm. What should I change it to?
ReplyDeleteI never meant that people who have kids only have them because they're so arrogant they want to see themselves in their kids! LOL! The thought of someone taking it that way never even entered my mind. Of COURSE it's because they want kids! LOL! What I meant was, they want kids, that's why, but they want to share blood with them or something. I don't know. When I say "kids that look like them" it's not in exclusion of kids that don't look like them, but just that generally in all societies we think families have to look alike, so "kids that look like them" just mean kids that obviously belong to them. I don't know why people want to give birth instead of adoption, except for the actual experience of giving birth and making a child together. Conception and pregnancy are amazing and miraculous. And I don't know why I'm a weirdo who wants to adopt instead of give birth!
How can you give back an adopted kid? The kid is YOURS legally in all ways. I don't understand how that can be allowed. I would bet that mom also ended up divorced, if she was ever married. There are some things that are supposed to be for as long as you're alive, like marriage and YOUR KIDS. There is no way out - you're stuck. Deal with it and learn to make it better.
One of my brothers is very different from both of my parents but there's no doubt he's theirs biologically because he looks like them. So personality and bonding is random no matter whether your kids are adopted or you gave birth to them.
I agree with all you said. Thanks for pointing out how that was coming across because I had no clue you thought I was calling you arrogant because your kids look like you! LOL! And of course, as always, thanks for your honesty. Your girls are all so lovely, and not just because they look like you. =o)
I don't think you're weird. I think God gave you a VERY special calling (and I'm jealous that you'll never have baby fat to lose! hehe) with regard to having your children by adoption.
ReplyDeleteAnd I never thought that was what you mean, just that that's how it comes across sometimes. I would think just saying something like "people want biological children" would do. It's not as catchy or funny, but it's more truthful. Cuz as much as I admire you, I really don't see myself adopting children. I'm perfectly happy with the ones I made. ;)