Monday, October 7, 2013

Why homeschooling?

Let me begin by saying that I don't believe homeschool is for everyone or that it is always or in all ways superior.* I believe that schooling should depend on each family's - kids' and parents' - needs, and should usually be reevaluated every year. For some families private school is the best. For others, public. For others, homeschool. For others, if they have access to it, a hybrid. What's best for each kid and each family depends on each kid and each family and it's not worth arguing about.

A little bit of background: I was homeschooled for my entire grade school career. When I was entering ninth grade my parents asked if my brothers and I wanted to go to regular school. Two of my brothers chose to go to regular school so they could play sports (there weren't many typical extracurriculars for homeschoolers at that time) but my youngest brother and I chose to stay home. Although I was interested in being in the high school plays, it wasn't enough to get me to want to be in school for eight hours and then come home and have homework. I liked my freedom and free time, and besides, I could play with my friends when they finally got home and finished their homework. I loved being homeschooled and to this day I learn so much better by reading or doing something for myself rather than being lectured at like I had to be in college. (But don't get me wrong; I did very well in college too, and I feel I owe a lot of that to having been homeschooled.)

My husband experienced the whole catalog of schooling options: he attended public, private, and homeschool. He disliked all of them and eventually quit high school early, got his GED, and went to college, where he excelled. Of course, his mom ran their homeschool quite differently than my mom ran ours, and I think he might've been OK with how my mom did it. Either way he agrees with the reasoning (and so far the results) for us homeschooling E and hopefully B.

Here are our reasons for homeschooling at this time:

  • Our local public schools are terrible. They score like 3 out of 10 on the school scoring sites. Every kid deserves a good education but E wouldn't get one at our nearby public schools. And since we're planning to spend about the equivalent of $10,000/year ($30,000ish every 3 years) adopting for the next probably 6-9 years, we can't afford to send him to private school. 
  • It seems like every kid I know is overscheduled, including the homeschoolers, but especially and by far the public/private schooled kids. It's hard not to be overscheduled when you're in school from 8-3, spend the next 2-3 hours in extended day, and then have an hour or two of homework. Throw in dinner and it's basically bed time since they have to wake up so early. If they have dance class or soccer practice or any other extracurriculars, they have no time to just be a kid. Research regularly shows that kids really need time to just play, and especially play outside. E is playing soccer, going to church kids club, going to church, and going to MOPS activities, and he still has plenty of time to use his imagination with cars, guys, and "playing the drums", as well as play and imagine and explore outside. When we add music or dance or karate one of these days it will be even more important for him to have lots of free play time.
  • I like my kid and I'd miss him if he were gone all day every day! I'd get a lot more done, and grocery shopping would be much easier, but I'd miss him. Plus I'd miss out on watching his eyes light up when he finally gets a concept or reads a big word with ease.

So there you go. We have several reasons and, so far, a little more than a month in, it's been good. But we'll reevaluate each year to be sure this is still what's best for him, me, and eventually B!

Have you considered homeschool? Why or why not?

* If we're being honest I do believe it is usually superior at least for the kid because it's hard to beat one-on-one and individually tailored learning.

No comments:

Post a Comment